Insights from a New Study
Menopause, a biological phenomenon primarily associated with human females, has long intrigued scientists due to its rarity in the animal kingdom. However, recent research suggests that whales, specifically five distinct species, also experience menopause.
This revelation prompts a deeper investigation into the evolutionary advantage of menopause, drawing parallels between whales and humans.
In the article by Carl Zimmer published in the NY Times on March 13, 2024, the focus is on a groundbreaking study led by Samuel Ellis, a biologist at the University of Exeter, that sheds light on why whales undergo menopause.
Contrary to common belief, menopause isn’t exclusive to humans and primates, mainly a single species of chimpanzees, but has been identified in five whale species. Dr. Ellis study delves into the evolutionary implications of menopause in these marine mammals.
Here are the key points:
- Evolutionary Advantage: The study proposes that menopause in whales provides females with an evolutionary advantage. By ceasing reproduction, older females can avoid resource conflicts with their offspring, thereby increasing the survival chances of their descendants. This finding challenges previous assumptions about the evolutionary purpose of menopause.
- Parallels with Humans: The study draws parallels between menopause in whales and humans, suggesting similar evolutionary benefits. In both species, menopause may facilitate the survival and well-being of offspring by redirecting resources and reducing intergenerational competition.
- Social Dynamics: The research emphasizes the importance of social dynamics in shaping the evolution of menopause. Whales, with their complex social structures and familial bonds, may have evolved menopause as a strategy to maintain cohesion within social groups.
- Research Methodology: The study utilized data from various whale species, comparing those that undergo menopause with related species that do not. Statistical analyses revealed patterns indicating the evolutionary significance of menopause in certain whale populations.
The study underscores the rarity of menopause in the animal kingdom and hints at the specific social dynamics required for its evolution. But do we truly know the evolution of menopause in mammals at all?
The Nature Podcast recently covered the topic discussing the intriguing phenomenon of menopause in killer whales and the recent findings elucidating its potential evolutionary purpose. Scientists propose that menopause in killer whales may confer an advantage by allowing older females to support their offspring rather than competing with them for resources. This unique reproductive strategy may enhance the survival of offspring and contribute to the cohesive social structure of killer whale pods. This social construct is also understood as the Grandmother Hypothesis.
The Grandmother Hypothesis, as referred to by Dr. Jen Gunter, in her book The Menopause Manifesto, is an evolutionary theory proposing that menopause and the extended post-reproductive lifespan in women may have evolved to allow older females to invest in the care and support of their grandchildren, thereby increasing the survival and reproductive success of their offspring. This hypothesis suggests that menopause may confer evolutionary advantages by redirecting resources towards supporting the survival of existing offspring rather than continuing to bear new offspring late into life.
It appears that females in limited mammal species possess a notable awareness of the fundamental principle that prioritizing the well-being of offspring is crucial for the survival and prosperity of the entire species. This recognition underscores the significance of nurturing and protecting offspring, a concept foundational to the continuation of the bloodline.
Th new study by Ellis and his research team is the beginning steps toward unraveling the evolutionary mystery of menopause in whales. By providing insights into the adaptive advantages of menopause, the research contributes to our understanding of reproductive strategies in marine mammals and their broader implications for evolutionary biology. Furthermore, the parallels drawn between whales and humans underscore the universality of biological phenomena across diverse species.
It is my aspiration that research endeavors such as this will foster heightened awareness and comprehension within the medical community regarding menopause as a significant biological transition in the female reproductive journey, warranting further investigation. This extends beyond considerations of social dynamics and evolutionary advantages to encompass the provision of health interventions that facilitate a nurturing, holistic, and accepting transition. By doing so, we aim to empower elder women to maintain their dignity within familial and societal contexts.
About the Author
Mary Lee is a PR practitioner turned Menoapause Doula based on Vancouver Island, Canada. With a passion for science communication and life sciences, she has been recognized for her work as a nominee for the PRNews Top Women in PR award in 2022.
Her insightful perspectives and in-depth studies to become a menopause doula and launch her own podcast, All Things Menopausal, on the subject of the menopausal transition make her articles and episodes both informative and engaging.
For more infomration about how to work with an ‘M’ Doula visit emmeellecoaching.com
Connect with Mary (a.k.a Coach Emme Elle) on Instagram at emme_elle_coaching.
Inside Emme Elle's Journal 
You must be logged in to post a comment.